'

Plaster perfect

Photo courtesy Mark Costa

A restoration team looked far and wide to match plaster from historic adobe.

In southern Arizona, dotting the literal U.S.-Mexico border, is Camp Naco -- a vestige of American history that a group of passionate individuals has worked to not only preserve but also resurrect as a functional and educational tribute to its past.

In 1911, Camp Naco began humbly as a tent camp to house African American Buffalo Soldiers from the 9th and 10th cavalry regiments, and later the 25th infantry regiment through 1923.

An archive photo of Camp Naco, courtesy Wanda Byme Collection, Bisbee Mining and Historical Museum
An archive photo of Camp Naco, courtesy Wanda Byme Collection, Bisbee Mining and Historical Museum.

Eight years later in 1919, a permanent encampment of 22 adobe buildings went up, and stayed up -- this complex is the only surviving post from the original 35 permanent camps along the border to protect incursions from the Mexican Revolution.

In 1937, the complex reverted to private ownership and remained that way for nearly 70 years.

Over the last 20 years or so, several factors have combined to save the property, including the formation in 2008 of the Naco Heritage Alliance, a 501(c) (3) organization aimed exclusively at preserving the property’s historic adobe buildings.

The parade grounds of Camp Naco are pictured. Photo courtesy Mark Costa
The parade grounds of Camp Naco are pictured. Photo courtesy Mark Costa

An important milestone occurred in 2012, when Camp Naco gained a listing on the National Register of Historic Places. The 16-acre property was acquired by the city of Bisbee, Ariz., in 2018; in 2022, it was listed on the 11 Most Endangered Historic Places list by the National Trust for Historic Preservation; and $8.1 million in grant money was awarded that same year to the Naco Heritage Alliance and City of Bisbee (from the Office of Arizona’s Governor and the Mellon Foundation). Combined, these developments have propelled the site toward rehabilitation as well as the development of community programming to sustain its use.

The plaster sample is pictured in AMT Laboratories.
The plaster sample is pictured in AMT Laboratories.

A tough match

According to Mike Normand, Construction Project Manager for the City of Bisbee, Ariz., a primary reason Camp Naco is still standing is what it’s made of.

“It was one of two (camps) constructed of adobe block, and we’re told that the adobe may have come from high clay content soil on the site,” he says. “The buildings have been vacant for decades. A group of volunteers were doing their best to maintain and preserve it. Over time, some of the buildings collapsed. Some were lost to fire. There are about 20 adobe buildings left that we’re trying to restore. One of the issues was the plaster.”

“We needed a recipe so we could reverse-engineer the plaster and duplicate it.”

In several places, areas of the adobe buildings’ exteriors, the plaster, which had been used to protect the adobe blocks as a coating, was in bad need of repair. To restore the plaster exteriors, Normand spearheaded a geological investigation.

“The plaster seemed to be unique,” Normand says. “We began trying to go back to the Army Corps of Engineers in 1919 to try to figure out the building typologies, the materials, who made those decisions and where did the materials come from?”

Normand contacted several labs in Arizona with few promising results.

An archive photo of Camp Naco courtesy the Charlotte Walker Lamb Collection, Bisbee Mining and Historical Museum
An archive photo of Camp Naco courtesy the Charlotte Walker Lamb Collection, Bisbee Mining and Historical Museum.

“We were trying to find a lab that could break down the sample of the plaster and tell us what the components were,” he says. “We needed a recipe so we could reverse-engineer the plaster and duplicate it.”

“I called several labs here in Arizona and talked to other adobe specialists. They said, ‘Oh, we don’t do that, but call this lab,’ and then they said, ‘No, we don’t do that type of testing.’ I was following all these leads, at labs not only in Arizona but all over the country. I finally was recommended to contact Courtney (Murdock) at AMT Labs, and she said, ‘Yes, we can do that.’”

Murdock, Director of Project Testing for AMT Labs, says each sample she receives for testing tells a unique story, but Camp Naco is one that stood out to her.

Courtney Murdock, Director of Project Testing for AMT Labs
Courtney Murdock is the Director of Project Testing for AMT Labs, which administers several specialty tests including mortar analysis, cleaning, consolidation, and petrographic analysis.

“I always love to hear the stories behind the samples that we are sent for evaluation, whether that is a petrographic analysis as in the case of Camp Naco, or one of our many other specialized tests like mortar analysis, cleaning, or consolidation,” she says. “Camp Naco’s history and revitalization were particularly fascinating to me, and we were honored to help the project team match the original plaster on these adobe buildings.”

With the results from AMT Labs’ petrographic analysis of the plaster, the Camp Naco team was ready to move forward.

“It was very helpful,” Normand says. “Now we have the recipe for the plaster for the architecture team. That’s where we are right now. We’re bringing on a contractor, and in the next few months, we’ll start the rehabilitation around the end of this year.”

“We needed a recipe so we could reverse-engineer the plaster and duplicate it," says Mike Normand, Construction Project Manager for the City of Bisbee, Ariz. Photo courtesy Mark Costa
“We needed a recipe so we could reverse-engineer the plaster and duplicate it," says Mike Normand, Construction Project Manager for the City of Bisbee, Ariz. Photo courtesy Mark Costa

A recipe to rebuild

With the results of the petrographic analysis from AMT Labs, the project team could move forward with the recipe to repair the plaster, which ended up being lime-based in composition. Normand said for its 100-year-old age, it held up remarkably well. “Ninety percent of the coverage was in good condition,” he says.

"We are beholden to standards of preservation, so (the plaster) needs to be matched to the highest degree possible of what was existing there."

The importance of repairing the plaster material with as close of a match as possible to the original was taken very seriously by the Camp Naco team.

“We are beholden to standards of preservation, so this needs to be matched to the highest degree possible of what was existing there,” says Brooks Jeffery, who was hired by the City of Bisbee as a strategic planning consultant to launch construction and community programming initiatives on the site.

“These buildings have survived and are thriving because of the protective coat that the plaster provided, so we want to replicate the recipe, but also take a scholarly kind of approach to talk about how we find the materials and do the investigative research.”

Barracks and officers club at Camp Naco. Photo courtesy Mark Costa
The petrographic analysis by AMT Labs helped the project team know how to precisely match the repair material to the original plaster on the adobe buildings. Photo courtesy Mark Costa

Of course, the plaster is only one component of the entire restoration effort at Camp Naco – an undertaking which is expected to be completed around 2026.

“There are some buildings where, before the roofs were repaired, water got into the building and eroded portions of the adobe walls,” Jeffery says. “There will be some reconstructing of some sections of the walls, and then there are seven structures that burned, and those will need to be rebuilt. Our plan is to have some workshops on site that can provide education and training about using adobe for construction. We’ll probably be making adobes on site from the materials native to this site. The soil here is very high in clay content and sand aggregate, which is ideal for mixing and making adobe blocks.”

Drone photography of Camp Naco, courtesy G. Lamb
Drone photography of Camp Naco, courtesy G. Lamb

Twenty adobe buildings will ultimately be restored to provide a variety of services and purposes for the underserved border community of Naco. One of the buildings, which was originally a hospital, will be an interpretive center about the history of Buffalo Soldiers. One will be a community center and library. The barracks buildings will be rehabbed into classrooms, workshops, and art studios, and open spaces that were previously parade grounds will be repurposed into outdoor venues. Former officers’ quarters will serve as housing for a caretaker, artists-in-residence, and local workforce.

“The Bisbee area is known for its heritage tourism with a thriving arts scene and a great community spirit,” Jeffery says. “That helped inform the three pillars to our vision for Camp Naco: 1) to honor the legacy of the Buffalo Soldiers in the American Southwest; 2) to advance the diverse arts, culture, and history of the Arizona Borderlands; and 3) to serve the community of Naco, Arizona.”

chevron-logo

PROSOCO's pallet tag program

Hard Surface Care

A prescription for masonry

Once your masonry wall is up, a prescription for its care will ensure it looks its best for years to come. Here's how to get it. Most materials of value come with a set of instructions on how to care for them. For everything from clothing and appliances to jewelry[…]

Cincinnati Union Terminal - photo courtesy Lang Masonry

Hard Surface Care

Cleaning an icon: Cincinnati Union Terminal

When a treasured, cultural asset like the Cincinnati Union Terminal (CUT) is restored, there are more stakeholders than in a typical construction project who are paying very close attention.   So, when Cincinnati, Ohio's historic train station and museum center was slated for a $228 million renovation beginning in 2016[…]

Anchor Systems

Saved from the brink of destruction

Uncared for and unoccupied for 18 years, Cook County Hospital in Chicago was ready for demo. Trees and plants growing inside and out, broken pipes, shattered window glass and a flooded basement belied the grandeur once embodied in this historic Beaux-Arts building with a virtuous legacy. Built in 1914, Cook[…]

Amanda Brown has been fascinated with headstones from an early age

Restoration

Dealing in death

Amanda Brown grew up in a bygone era where "you couldn't come home until the streetlights came on." Stuck outside but equipped with a bicycle, Brown would meander around her hometown of historic Aberdeen, Washington, and often find herself at a big cemetery across the hill from Wishkah Valley. "It[…]

Anchor Systems

A place of their own

St. Luke African Methodist Episcopal Church in Lawrence, Kan., is a story worth preserving. This is the place where civil rights activists gathered in the 1960s to organize protests and marches in downtown Lawrence, Kan. It’s the place where famed poet Langston Hughes attended Sunday church service with his “Auntie[…]

Pull-testing services are complimentary when working with PROSOCO's Anchoring Systems

Anchor Systems

What is a pull test, and why would I need one?

PROSOCO's Jeff Scarpelli shares what you need to know about this test of wall strength. Whether a pull test is requested, or required, on your project, you may be wondering why it's needed, what it measures, and what to do with the results. To answer these questions, we sat down[…]